Posts in Bid Protest
Is it OK to underbid an SCA Contract?

Businesses competing for federal contracts will be successful if they are able to offer high quality products and services for a reasonable price when compared with the offerings of their competitors. A recent bid protest decision issued by the Government Accountability Office offers a poignant reminder about how challenging it can be to come up with a price to perform a federal service contract.

Read More
How Low Can You Go? GAO Rejects Protest Alleging Below Cost Wage Rates

Here’s some old news that bears repeating. When it comes to prices offered to the Government to perform a fixed-price service contract, GAO won’t second guess the award of a contract with low-ball prices even though it might appear there’s no way the contractor would pay the minimum wage rates required by the Service Contract Act.

Read More
A Look Behind the Curtain: Recent Bid Protest Decision Offers Insight into Corrective Actions

Conventional wisdom holds that bid protests are an uphill battle. It can be tough to win them. And sometimes when you win, you still lose because the contract’s still awarded to your competitor. A recent bid protest decision illustrates how a successful protest prompted the agency to appoint a new evaluation team that changed the outcome.

Read More
Check the Water Before You Dive In: GAO Rejects Protest that Government Should Have Clarified Application of Service Contract Act

Contractors are on their own when it comes to determining what wages they must pay under a contract covered by the Service Contract Act. That’s exactly what the Government Accountability Office held when it denied the protest of a prospective contractor that sought a ruling about when under a diving services contract it should pay prevailing wages to its divers.

Read More
Left at the Altar: What to do if Key Personnel Proposed for a Service Contract Break their Commitments?

Many service contracts require that certain jobs, i.e., “key positions,” be held by highly qualified personnel dedicated to the project. So, what happens if that rock star project manager you spent months recruiting for a “key position” bails out on you in the middle of the competition to win the very contract the rock star was proposed to manage?

Read More
COFC Rejects Sole Source Procurement to Replace Out-of-Favor Incumbent

The Court of Federal Claims sustained the protest of a contractor that argued that the Government could not hire a replacement contractor through the use of an improperly justified sole source acquisition. The Court set aside the new award—a result that likely will require the Government to continue working with a contractor with which it allegedly was dissatisfied. Should an agency have the ability to make a change using a sole source procurement? In the commercial world, feathers might get ruffled, but a jilted vendor wouldn’t be able to get a court to throw out a replacement. In our world, it’s all different.

Read More
Bid Protest Delays: Can a contractor recover the cost of paying someone to do nothing?

You just won a contract. You brought that brilliant project manager on board. Then, your competitor files a protest and you have to stop work. What do you do to keep that manager in the stable? A recent case at the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals denied a contractor the cost of doing something quite reasonable—keeping the manager on board.

Read More